| Platinum | Pepper's Pizza & Subs |
| Gold | Zummo's Cafe |
| Silver | Pizza By Pappas |
| Bronze | Stirna's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Cara Mia's Delicatessen |
| Top Pick | Carmellas Italian Deli & Pastries |
| Top Pick | Colarusso's In Clarks Summit |
| Top Pick | Cosmos Cheesesteaks |
| Top Pick | Hanks Hoagies |
| Top Pick | Roseanna's Pizza |