| Platinum | Cosmik Gifts |
| Gold | Esthers Consignment Boutique |
| Silver | Goodwill Stores |
| Bronze | Miriam's Furniture Consignment |
| Top Pick | Fabulous Finds |
| Top Pick | Old & Brew |
| Top Pick | Terenzio's Closet |
| Top Pick | The Avenue Consignment Shoppe |
| Top Pick | The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center |
| Top Pick | Upstairsthrift |