| Platinum | Minooka Pastry Shop |
| Gold | Gerrity's Supermarket |
| Silver | Michele's Sugar Shack |
| Bronze | Cookies By Marissa |
| Top Pick | Bella Baketique |
| Top Pick | My Mother's Delicacies |
| Top Pick | National Bakery |
| Top Pick | National Pastry Bake Shop |
| Top Pick | Osborne Specialties |
| Top Pick | Queen Of Tarts |