| Platinum | Angie's Pizza |
| Gold | Maroni's Pizza House |
| Gold | Valley Pizza 570 |
| Silver | Acaro & Genell |
| Bronze | Nicholas Pizza Shop |
| Top Pick | Andy's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Buona Pizza & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Giavannas Pizza |
| Top Pick | Novellos Pizza |
| Top Pick | Sacco's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant |