| Platinum | Lynn Sandy's Cakes |
| Gold | Minooka Pastry Shop |
| Silver | Queen Of Tarts |
| Bronze | Maximum Zen |
| Bronze | Wegmans Market Cafe |
| Top Pick | Black Cat Bakery |
| Top Pick | Cwikla's Quality Bakery |
| Top Pick | Evil Sweets by Lulu |
| Top Pick | Giant Food |
| Top Pick | Pilger's Pastries |