| Platinum | Cara Mia's Delicatessen |
| Gold | Taylor Deli & Cafe |
| Silver | Caramanno's Deli |
| Bronze | Steve and Irenes |
| Top Pick | Carmellas Italian Deli & Pastries |
| Top Pick | Catalanos |
| Top Pick | Downtown Deli |
| Top Pick | Hanks Hoagies |
| Top Pick | Roseanna's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rossi's Ristorante |