| Platinum | The 1905 Tavern |
| Gold | Honeychilds |
| Silver | 3 Jacks Burger Bar |
| Bronze | Otown Bar and Gril |
| Top Pick | Buddy Clarke's |
| Top Pick | Coney Island |
| Top Pick | Cosmos Cheesesteaks |
| Top Pick | Loading Dock Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | Novellos Pizza |
| Top Pick | Olde Brook Inn |