| Platinum | Ragnacci's Family Restaurant |
| Gold | Schiff's Cash & Carry |
| Silver | Cracker Barrel |
| Silver | Ethan's Eats |
| Bronze | Chef von & Mom |
| Top Pick | BackBurner Cafe & Catering Company |
| Top Pick | Honeychilds |
| Top Pick | Nonno's Pizza and Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Nonnos Pasta |
| Top Pick | Old Country Buffet |