| Platinum | Rosarios |
| Gold | Colarusso's In Clarks Summit |
| Silver | Grande Pizza Moosic |
| Bronze | Casa Bella |
| Top Pick | Alfredo's |
| Top Pick | Angelo's Italian Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Dino & Francesco's |
| Top Pick | Pronto |
| Top Pick | Ragnacci's Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Rossi's Ristorante |