| Platinum | The 1905 Tavern |
| Gold | Honeychilds |
| Silver | Pepper's Pizza & Subs |
| Bronze | Chef von & Mom |
| Top Pick | Alfredo's |
| Top Pick | Cosmos Cheesesteaks |
| Top Pick | Dutchie's Pizza, Subs and Take Away |
| Top Pick | Hanks Hoagies |
| Top Pick | Jimmy John's Clark's Summit |
| Top Pick | Steve and Irenes |
| Main Street Bagel |