| Platinum | Heaven & Earth Gift Shop |
| Gold | This Must Be The Place |
| Silver | Dragonfly Dreamer LLC |
| Bronze | The Curiosity Shop |
| Top Pick | Dixon Candle and Bath |
| Top Pick | Nibbles & Bits |
| Top Pick | Nick D.'s Video Game Vault |
| Top Pick | Noteology |
| Top Pick | The Avenue Consignment Shoppe |
| Top Pick | The Wonderstone Gallery |