| Platinum | Armetta's Restaurant & Pizza |
| Platinum | Casa Bella |
| Gold | Dino & Francesco's |
| Silver | Sibio's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Picciocchi's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | A Little Pizza Heaven |
| Top Pick | Abbiocco |
| Top Pick | Alfredo's |
| Top Pick | Brick Oven Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Sacco's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant |