| Platinum | Dixon Candle and Bath |
| Gold | Dragonfly Dreamer LLC |
| Gold | Heaven & Earth Gift Shop |
| Silver | 9th House Knits & Gifts |
| Bronze | From Earth to Jupiter |
| Top Pick | Jerry's For All Seasons |
| Top Pick | Little Bird Revival |
| Top Pick | Pigeon Post |
| Top Pick | Pure Suds Co. |
| Top Pick | Violets a Little Bit of Everything |